QA MadnessBlog Every Product Needs Acceptance and Production Verification Testing. Here’s Why
Every Product Needs Acceptance and Production Verification Testing. Here’s Why
Reading Time: 7minutes
When working on software, there might come a moment when you doubt whether it’s enough. These reservations might become a hindrance if your team is a part of a startup or smaller project with no deep software testing expertise. But if you’re hesitant, it means you’re doing something right. It means you care about the quality.
Today, we discuss two types of testing that help you gain confidence in your work: acceptance and production verification testing.
Explaining Acceptance Testing
Acceptance testing evaluates whether the software meets specified criteria derived from project documentation. It aims at validating the product’s alignment with requirements and consumer expectations. Let’s review what it does in practice by considering different types of acceptance testing.
User acceptance testing – does the product work as intended for the users?
Business acceptance testing – does it align with business requirements and goals?
Contract acceptance testing – does it deliver based on the terms defined in contracts (e.g., SLAs)?
Regulation acceptance testing – does it conform to the regulatory norms?
Operational acceptance testing – does it meet operational requirements (e.g., performance, interoperability, backup, recovery, and maintainability)?
Essentially, acceptance testing is like checking the boxes of your plan for the day. If you’ve completed everything – success. If you’ve missed something, well, you’ll have to come back tomorrow. In other words, acceptance testing is assessing what has been done so far and whether it was done right.
So, when you run it, you can:
Ensure the software meets business requirements and regulatory compliance.
Locate defects missed during system testing.
Engage end-user perspective.
Assess the effectiveness of current software testing services.
Acceptance testing usually takes place in the later stages of the SDLC. You’d want to run it after systems tests and before deployment. Typically, its execution is seen as the “final checkup”. But it can also:
Occur throughout the development process in Agile and DevOps for continuous feedback.
Happen when introducing updates, customization, or seeking regulatory compliance.
Hence, acceptance testing sometimes shifts from being the last touch-up to being a qualification tool. And so, you might think, “How is it different from prior testing phases?” Acceptance testing doesn’t really “go over” prior tests, it centers on users’ points of view.
For instance, system testing focuses on technical aspects of a product (does it work correctly?). Acceptance testing is about the people (does it work correctly for the consumer?). For the latter, think of consumers as everyone related to the software. Remember the types of acceptance testing? Consumers can be:
End-users.
Stakeholders.
The team.
Regulatory bodies, etc.
Briefly, these tests confirm that the product is “the right thing” for everyone involved.
Explaining Production Verification Testing
Production verification testing (PVT) affirms that the product meets design and performance requirements and reliably functions in a production environment. It validates the product’s readiness for mass production or market release.
You may be a bit confused at this point, “Isn’t PVT the same as acceptance testing then?” We’ll cover their core differences later, don’t worry. But for now, think about these two like this:
Acceptance tests are about what has been done so far.
And PVT is about how things are going now.
So, production verification testing aims to evaluate how the product works in a live environment when subjected to real-world scenarios.
When to Run Production Verification Testing?
Like acceptance testing, you’d conduct PVT after the initial product development and design phases. But you can also run it as a part of:
Risk mitigation.
Pilot testing.
Pilot production.
It may depend on the project’s complexity. Yet, generally, it takes place just before the software enters full-scale production. It allows you to:
Ensure the live build is working as needed.
Locate any issues that might have happened during the release.
Check all critical elements.
Acceptance Testing vs Production Verification Testing
Now, to make things clearer, let’s review how exactly acceptance testing and PVT differ and where they overlap a bit.
Similarities
Both focus on assuring the quality and readiness of a product.
They involve verifying that the software meets specified requirements and criteria.
The two serve as final checks before mass production to ensure alignment with expectations.
Differences
Acceptance testing is a part of the development stage. PVT is the first official production run that usually takes a couple of hours.
Acceptance testing is run in a simulated production environment. PVT is run in a live environment.
Acceptance testing occurs at the end of the software development lifecycle before deployment. PVT takes place during the product development lifecycle, before mass production or market release.
Acceptance testing verifies that the product meets the designed acceptance criteria. PVT makes sure that the final build is functioning correctly in its final environment.
Acceptance testing focuses on user-specific functionality, usability, and alignment with business goals. PVT verifies the product’s design, reliability, and production processes.
Acceptance testing may involve end-user testing to obtain authentic feedback. PVT needs the QA and development teams to create test accounts and data.
QA Audit Checklist for Documentation Review
Acceptance Testing
Production Verification Testing
Is a part of the development stage.
Is the first official production run that usually takes a couple of hours.
Is run in a simulated production environment.
Is run in a real, live environment.
Occurs at the end of the software development lifecycle before deployment.
Takes place during the product development lifecycle, before mass production or market release.
Verifies that the product meets the designed acceptance criteria.
Makes sure that the final build is functioning correctly in its final environment.
Focuses on user-specific functionality, usability, and alignment with business goals.
Verifies the product’s design, reliability, and production processes.
May involve end-user testing to obtain authentic feedback.
Needs the QA and development teams to create test accounts and data.
To summarize, acceptance testing centers on hitting all the checkmarks, and PVT focuses on evaluating how everything works live.
How Acceptance Testing and PVT Define Product Readiness
So, how do you know that your product is release- and mass production-ready? With acceptance testing and PVT, you just need to pass each criterion, which, of course, depends on your project. In other words, not all criteria are the same. That’s why we’ll focus on universal readiness denominators.
Based on acceptance tests, your product is ready when it:
Aligns with project requirements.
Offers stable performance and functionality.
Is error-free (as much as it’s possible).
Conforms to business goals.
Is easy to use and provides a positive user experience.
Adheres to specific industry standards, compliance, or regulatory requirements.
Can handle expected workloads and scale as necessary.
Is secure and consistent.
All these signify that, indeed, the right software was built and that each user is likely to be satisfied with the result.
And regarding PVT, your project is ready for mass production when it:
Can function properly and reliably in a real-world setting.
Doesn’t show significant issues or performance bottlenecks.
Runs continuously and reliably without crashes or failures.
Is easy to use across various environments (devices, operating systems, browsers, etc.).
Handles errors and exceptions properly.
Performs well under the expected load and usage conditions.
Can scale effectively to accommodate increased demands.
Meets the quality standards set for mass production and deployment.
These mean that your software will be able to handle the wilderness of live usage in the long term.
Why Pay Attention to Acceptance Testing and PVT?
Failed acceptance testing means the product won’t be satisfactory to consumers. And unsuccessful PVT means users won’t enjoy the product to the fullest and that it may be short-lived. If you find certain criteria unfulfilled, you might need to take a step back.
For example, during acceptance testing, you can find:
Issues in the software’s business logic or workflows, affecting the overall operation of the app.
Difficulties in understanding or operating the software, resulting in poor user experience.
Non-adherence to legal or industry regulations, requiring adjustments for compliance.
Any of these would mean that the developers and QA engineers need to refine the product further and adjust their testing strategy for better coverage. So, acceptance testing determines the quality of the product and defines the effectiveness of your QA resources.
And with PVT, you may come across:
Problems related to the deployment process, such as configuration issues or compatibility troubles with the production environment.
Errors when handling increased user loads, data volumes, or transactions, as well as scalability concerns.
New defects or issues introduced during the deployment process, including regression defects.
In these cases, you’d need to conduct root-cause analysis and fix any issues before committing to mass production. It’s like releasing a sanctuary animal into the wild. Even if you simulate all natural conditions, you never know what might happen or go wrong. So, you’d need to monitor it, help it adapt, and see what could’ve been done better.
Both acceptance and production verification testing are highly personalized. You probably won’t find recommendations that suit your project fully. But that’s completely fine. In software development, there aren’t really any one-fits-all solutions. So, treat every best practice you come across as something that has proven its worth and as a guideline rather than a rule.
Acceptance Testing Tips
Start planning for acceptance testing as early as possible. It’ll help you avoid rushed or incomplete testing at the end of the project.
Include end-users (if possible), business owners, and other stakeholders in the acceptance testing process. You’d want to ensure full consideration of their expectations and requirements.
Clearly define acceptance criteria in collaboration with stakeholders. They should outline the specific conditions the software should meet to be accepted.
Use real-world data or data that closely resembles real-world scenarios to secure correct product performance.
Create a testing environment that mirrors the production environment. This way, you can be sure of your software’s authentic behavior in real-world conditions.
Run end-to-end testing to simulate genuine user journeys and validate proper integrations.
Encourage open communication and collaboration between QA specialists, developers, and stakeholders to address issues promptly and provide timely feedback.
Production Verification Testing Tips
Set clear expectations regarding the scope and purpose of post-production release verification. This way, the team knows exactly what to do, streamlining testing and lifting productivity.
Develop a post-production release verification test plan for easier and organized testing.
Include the most important and critical steps that allow maximum functionality coverage.
Verify major impact areas for stable performance.
Use defect management tools to facilitate root cause analysis and traceability.
Carry out data clean-up after completing the verification to avoid unnecessary influence on the system.
Supplement in-production testing with pre-production testing (don’t replace one with the other) to minimize disruption in a live environment.
Frankly, the one “best practice” that is actually the best practice is finding the right people for your project. Your team makes all the difference.
You may be inclined to view acceptance and production verification testing as “leftover” checks. With so much work done already, why bother too much now? But they are like the final exams for your software. Sure, you’ve passed the monthly and mid-term tests. But the finals are the true proof that you’ve learned something.
Acceptance testing and PVT demonstrate that your efforts were directed properly, your team realized their potential, and your project is indeed its best version at the moment. Most importantly, passing these two means that you and your product are now ready for greater things.
Gain more confidence in your product – let’s discuss its testing
In honor of Women's Day, we would like to pay tribute to the women in Information Technology. Modern IT world viewed only as "a boy's thing". But this is not totally true. A lot of computing pioneers — the people who programmed the first digital computers — were women. Now, less than 25% of the IT workforce are women, but in the software testing sector the percentage filled by women is now approaching 50%. Women’s typical cognitive differences make them invaluable to IT teams. Let's pay attention to the history. One might believe that women did not play an important role in the beginnings of computer science, but in reality they have made significant contributions in many areas, starting from the early days. In any discussion of the pioneers in computing, the names of two visionaries immediately come to mind:
Augusta Ada Byron Lovelace (1815 – 1852). She is ...
First of all, what is “software bug”? Everyone understands that it isn’t an insect ( well, not anymore, anyway :-) ). According to Wikipedia: software bug is an error, flaw, failure, or fault in a computer program or system that causes it to produce an incorrect or unexpected result, or to behave in unintended ways.” Some bugs can be detected easily during development. But some bugs might be found late in the development process. There have been many attempts to classify the bugs. Most of these represent the general classification which is valid in the cycle of software development and evolution. The classification scheme given in Orthogonal Defect Classification defines eight categories of defects as assignment, checking, algorithm, interface, timing/serial, function documentation, and build/pack/merge. Most everything in such classification understandable, useful and boring. But, sometimes, going through a code, you may face a dark horse from the bug's world. There are ...
Software testing is the process of evaluation a software item to detect differences between given input and expected output. Software testing is a process that should be done during the development process. In other words, software testing is a verification and validation process.
This article is devoted to highlighting the most popular software testing tools nowadays.
Performance Testing Tools:
Here are some important tools to test the performance, load and stress of the website/application. These tools ensure that your website/application will run under high performance and less load & stress.
Apache JMeter is a 100% pure Java desktop application designed to load test functional behavior and measure performance...
What is your association with term "superhero"? For many of you, the image of superhero will remind you about the feeling of reliability and protection. Each superhero stands against the evil force by day and night. I'll reveal one amazing secret to you today... At the spare time, between fights against crime, brave superheroes protect your websites and apps! Yes, superheroes working as testers for a long time! Think about it... They are hidden in the shadows. No rest, no peace, no sleep until they capture a villain and hand them over to the authorities. They are the Keepers of your reputation in the Digital World! Nevertheless, who are they? Let the Secret be revealed!
Who: Captain America
How to find out: supercorrect, strict, the true patriot. His mind is only about the "quality, quality, quality", and is better not to joke with him. Havi...
Magento, as one of the leading eCommerce platforms, is used to create the most successful and high-quality online stores. The great variety of eCommerce websites, make quite serious competition on the market and the main point that will help you to be on the Toplist is Quality. Without proper testing, "sketchy" websites may face a number of challenges after launch. Based on our experience, we have compiled a list of the most "popular" bugs that we faced during Magento testing. Here are the most common of them:
Bug #1: You can’t rate the product or write a review for it.
It’s not the most critical bug, but it still can bugs people. The lack of opportunities to share their experiences with others can bring customers to the idea that you don't want to have truthful reviews on the website, so this may push for the idea that something is wrong with your product. ...
1. Your Store Policies Are Not Clear or Are Too Restrictive
Buying online is convenient, but people look for brick and mortar style assurance, too. They want to know they can easily return products or contact someone about trouble with your service.
2. Not Flexible Shipping Options
Free shipping is big with shoppers, and is quickly becoming an industry standard. Maybe this isn’t within your budget, but you may be able to shift some numbers around to make it fly. Testing will reveal what works best for you. Just make sure customers are aware of your free shipping option if you offer it.
3. Not Mobile Friendly
If you haven’t overhauled your design in the past two years, here’s your likely problem. Studies show that mobile shoppers acco...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
Cookie
Duration
Description
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional
11 months
The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy
11 months
The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.